Best/Worst Albums of 2005 [Archive]

View Full Version : Best/Worst Albums of 2005

Sprite

02-01-2006, 12:38 AM

Lets try and sort out HalfLife2.net's albums of the year :D Post your opinions here. Strangely, all my favourite albums are debuts...

Best
Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
A mature debut album mixing fusion, art-rock, post-punk and indie perfectly. With it's mix of romantic and subtle political lyrics, Kele's emotional and energetic vocals, and fantastic riffs will blow you away. Based on a 20-year old's view of the "Western World", the album combines frantic anti-Bush/Iraq War songs with beautiful, mellow relationship songs. Over-rated? No way. My album of the year.

Stand-out tracks:

Helicopter
She's Hearing Voices
Banquet
Luno
This Modern Love
So Here We Are

Maximo Park - A Certain Trigger
A much calmer album than others on this list, but is stunning. Every song is a sing-along with fantastic smooth vocals (complete with Geordie accent :p) and thoughtful lyrics. Catchy riffs and keyboards combine with the charisma of the vocals and create a truly unique sound.

Stand-out tracks:

Apply Some Pressure
Grafitti
Postcard of a Painting
Going Missing
The Coast is Always Changing

The Rakes - Capture/Release
A refreshingly British album with some very catchy tunes. A must-have for any indie fan.

Stand-out tracks:

Strasbourg
22 Grand Job
Retreat
Open Book
We Are All Animals
Work, Work, Work (Pub, Club, Sleep)

Nine Black Alps - Everything Is
A simple mixture of tuneful punk and grunge. Bears much of a resemblance to some Nirvana, but don't be put off. Great lyrics, vocals, riffs and structures to each song. Song of the album is Cosmopolitan.

Stand-out tracks:

Get Your Guns
Cosmopolitan
Unsatisfied
Shot Down

Art Brut - Bang Bang Rock 'n' Roll
A brilliant and funny art-rock band. Lyrics are both hilarious and genius, this unique sound is easy to fall in love with. "I want to be the boy, the man, who writes the song that makes Israel and Palestine get along"

Stand-out tracks:

Emily Kane
Formed A Band
Moving to LA
Rusted Guns
Bad Weekend

Worst
Hard-Fi - Stars of CCTV
What the hell is this? Awful vocals and shocking lyrics. Tracks are bland and repetitive, and unbeliavably over-rated.

Arcade Fire - Funeral
People will hurt me for saying this but this did nothing for me. Although I can see why they appeal to many people, they are hugely over-rated by NME, their vocals are whiney and the band seem arrogant. Only track which stands-out is Rebellion (Lies).

Kaiser Chiefs - Employment
It really is unbeliavable how many people fall for the hype surrounding the KCs, people are comparing them to Blur FFS! This album will bore you to tears. The songs are samey, predictable, corny and unimaginative. After the singles the album is just fillers, a total waste of money and space in the music industry. Terrible, just terrible. Go buy Bloc Party instead.

Coldplay - X&Y
Yes people, this is one of the worst albums of the year. I was a Coldplay fan until this arrived, and wasn't everyone expecting something phenomenal seeing as Chris Martin has been sitting on his rich ass for 18 months? Instead we got a bland third album with no identity whatsoever. Only redeeming feature is the energetic Speed Of Sound, after that the songs are unimaginative, boring and an utter waste of time. The riffs are dreary and sound the same all the way through the album. Avoid at all costs, DON'T believe the hype on this one.

One's to Watch
Arctic Monkeys - Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Out January 30th (UK Release)
A genuine bunch of lads producing genuine British sounds. This WILL be the album of 2006, a mixture of catchy riffs, rough yet great vocals and bloody amazing lyrics. With the combination of beautiful tracks like Mardy Bum to the fantastic energy of Sun Goes Down, this is a brilliant, genius first album. Features two of what will be THE anthems of 2006; When The Sun Goes Down and A Certain Romance.

Stand-out tracks:

I Bet You Look Good On The Dancefloor
When The Sun Goes Down (Scummy)
From The Ritz To The Rubble
A Certain Romance
Fake Tales of San Francisco
Still Take You Home
Mardy Bum

The Strokes - First Impressions of Earth - Out January 2nd (UK Release)
After the disappointment of Room On Fire, we will be expecting something fresh from The Strokes. This new album has been said to have the genius of the debut Is This It? with new funky riffs, such as the fantastic single Juicebox. Out tomorrow, go check it out.

Dirty Pretty Things
Lastly, Carl Barat of the Libertines has a new band reported to be bringing back their unique indie-rock sound. Carl is a genius songwriter and musician, and as well as covering Libertines classics, this will be a band to watch in 2006.

Well that's my list! Make your own lists and comment on each others!

Lucid

02-01-2006, 12:45 AM

A bit late for 2005...
But w/e.

Best : 10,000 Fists - Disturbed & Transgression - Fear Factory
Worst : In The End - Kittie

... meh I didn't buy many albums this year...

Cormeh

02-01-2006, 12:59 AM

Worst

Coldplay - X&Y
Yes people, this is one of the worst albums of the year. I was a Coldplay fan until this arrived, and wasn't everyone expecting something phenomenal seeing as Chris Martin has been sitting on his rich ass for 18 months? Instead we got a bland third album with no identity whatsoever. Only redeeming feature is the energetic Speed Of Sound, after that the songs are unimaginative, boring and an utter waste of time. The riffs are dreary and sound the same all the way through the album. Avoid at all costs, DON'T believe the hype on this one.

I appreciate that's your opinion, but that's my best album of 2005. Although there were a few songs that were pretty crap, it's a damn good album and Coldplay continue to improve. Fix You, White Shadows and Twisted Logic to name a few are fantastic.

Worst album? Oasis - Don't beleive the truth. I felt let down by this one. :(

Hectic Glenn

02-01-2006, 01:06 AM

I appreciate that's your opinion, but that's my best album of 2005. Although there were a few songs that were pretty crap, it's a damn good album and Coldplay continue to improve. Fix You, White Shadows and Twisted Logic to name a few are fantastic.
QFT, coldplay haters jump in and label it shit, without listening, X&Y owns your mother****ing cat. Fix you, Talk, A message, Swallowed in the Sea, Hardest Part, Speed of Sound, Till kingdom Come? Songs that are brilliant in every respect. I do not understand you people...

edit: My Mrs loves Bloc Party's album, personally i find it bland, their songs sound similar to my ear. Seem to be a bunch of random, almost geeky looking individuals who can play instruments...just.

DeusExMachina

02-01-2006, 01:07 AM

I definitely found Bloc Party's "Silent Alarm" overrated. A good album, but hey, I'd rather listen to Arcade Fire's Funeral which I thought was an average album as well.

Let's see albums of the year...

Sigur Ros-Takk-Beauty.
Architecture in Helsinki-A fun, thrilling, and a joy to listen to.
Devendra Banhart-Cripple Crow-Banhart's folk pop is always a joy and this is no exception.

And last...BUT NOT LEAST!

Weezer-Make Believe-LIEK OMFG GREATEST ALBUM EVA. BETTA THUN BLUE AND PINKERTON COMBINED!!!?!?!??!!!111!!

I'm kidding on so many levels :|.

ComradeBadger

02-01-2006, 01:19 AM

The Best

Art Brut - Bang Bang Rock & Roll

:D (I agree with Sprite)

Maximo Park - A Certain Trigger

Again, agreement :o

The Rakes - Capture/Release

Mmmmm :E

Right, on the original section of my list

Death Cab For Cutie - Plans

Smooth, inspired indie from the USA. Essentially a follow-up to Tranatlanicism, and improves upon it. Gentle sweet music, if slightly on a down note.

Stand out tracks:

Soul Meets Body
Summer Skin
I Will Follow You Into The Dark
Someday You Will Be Loved
Crooked Teeth

The Paddingtons - First Comes First

Don't listen to the demos they produced, listen to the album, the difference is staggering. Very punky, energetic 'grot n roll', very catchy tunes. Despite a slightly disappointing opening in Some Old Girl, the album picks up from there, and keeps going on until the end of the fantastic, sarcastic Sorry. Bonus points for coming from Hull and being decent :E

Stand Out Tracks:

First Comes First
50 to a £
Panic Attack
21
Sorry

Honourable Mentions

Babyshambles - Down In Albion
I like it, and wish Pete luck in cleaning up his act (I still have a flame for the Libertines ;( ) and continuing with this sideproject.
The New Pornographers - Twin Cinema
It's odd, it's intense, it's pretty and it's good.
The Subways - Young For Eternity
Anthemic, energetic and above all fun teenage music.

The Worst

Coldplay - X&Y
Having been a fan of Coldplay since they were on the Blue Room, and Paracutes being one of the first CD albums I bought, I was mightily disappointed with X&Y. Utterly forgettable, dull dull dull.

Interpol - Antics
Another album that actually feels like a chore to listen to. The singles have been interesting (Slow Hands and the one I forget with the lyric 'people are fragile things you should know by now' ) but the rest of the album is frankly disappointing. A waste of a good voice and some good ideas.

The Bravery - The Bravery
The album's mostly filler, you're cocks. Please stop.

Nirvana - Silver: The Best Of The Box
I think we're scraping away the floor beneath the barrel now. Such a shame.

Runner up:

The White Stripes - Get Behind Me Satan
This is what happens when people don't buy De Stij :p but seriously, a disappointing album from one of my favourite bands.

Ones To Watch

Aside from the previously mentioned forthcoming releases from the Arctic Monkeys, Dirty Pretty Things and The Strokes I'd point you in the direction of The Spinto Band, who's bizzare, folksy indie has me interested so far :)

Oh, and the band I'm forming (joking joking... :D )

DeusExMachina

02-01-2006, 01:23 AM

God I hope the Bravery die in a fiery lava pit.

But I liked Antics :).

Evo

02-01-2006, 01:31 AM

Best:

Nine Inch Nails - With Teeth (was 2005 i think?!) - simply awe inspiring
Iron Maiden - Death on the Road - one of the best live albums ever
Prodigy - Greatest Hits - pretty cool
Roadrunner United -brilliant tracks by artists on an awesome label

Worst/Should've been better

SOAD - both albums, while cool, were over hyped for what they were. Miss thier glory days of debut and Toxicity
QOTSA - Lullabyse to Paralyse - bit meh really

Sprite

02-01-2006, 01:35 AM

The Best

The Paddingtons - First Comes First

Don't listen to the demos they produced, listen to the album, the difference is staggering. Very punky, energetic 'grot n roll', very catchy tunes. Despite a slightly disappointing opening in Some Old Girl, the album picks up from there, and keeps going on until the end of the fantastic, sarcastic Sorry. Bonus points for coming from Hull and being decent :E

Stand Out Tracks:

First Comes First
50 to a £
Panic Attack
21
Sorry

Yep, agreed. Forgot about the Paddingtons, nice fresh energetic post-punk which will have you on ya feet.

Honourable Mentions

Babyshambles - Down In Albion
I like it, and wish Pete luck in cleaning up his act (I still have a flame for the Libertines ;( ) and continuing with this sideproject.

The Subways - Young For Eternity
Anthemic, energetic and above all fun teenage music.

Down In Albion never came close to the brilliance of Up The Bracket :(
I'm sure Pete could do much better if he wasn't such a mess, although Kilamangiro, F*ck Forever and some other tracks are great.

Also an interesting debut from the Subways. Produced some massive fun hits and I'll be looking forward to seeing what's ahead of them.

The Worst

The Bravery - The Bravery
The album's mostly filler, you're cocks. Please stop.

Runner up:

The White Stripes - Get Behind Me Satan
This is what happens when people don't buy De Stij :p but seriously, a disappointing album from one of my favourite bands.

Haha, so true about the Bravery... shocking album from well... a bunch of complete morons.

I was undecided over Get Behind Me Satan... it seemed like the rock tunes of Elephant and Red Blood Cells were growing a bit distant and they needed to come more mainstream and that's where they went wrong. Apart from the sublime Blue Orchid, My Doorbell and The Nurse, the album ultimately sucked...

Overall, while both SOAD albums are great (and provided some great numbers for the New Year's party :p), Evo is right. They should stop pissing around and bring out an album to rival Toxicity.

pomegranate

02-01-2006, 01:37 AM

Hmm, not been a vintage year for new music, IMO, but my favourite 2005 releases are:

Mylo: Destroy Rock and Roll

Adam Green: Gemstones

Gorillaz: Demon Days: Only just started listening to it this week, is surprisingly good, cos the first couple of singles didn't do much for me, and Gorillaz never did before.

M.I.A.: Arular: Something a bit different. I liked it a lot, massively varied and tuneful. Quite retro in places too, but fresh at the same time.

Basement Jaxx: The Singles: Okay this doesn't technically qualify as it's a compilation of older stuff, but the remixes and pre-Remedy stuff is brilliant.

Disapointments/Let Downs:

Weezer: Make Believe. Nothing massively compelling, really.

Girls Aloud: Chemistry. Almost all the decent tunes were released as singles before the album came out. There's a lot of filler otherwise. ("Models" rocks though). Ditto for Rachel Stevens' new album.

Goldfrapp: Supernature: More or less a watered down version of the previous album, Black Cherry. Irritates me that this got more hype than the previous albums. I really hope the next release is closer to the experiments of the first album, Felt Mountain, which was a total different kettle of fish.

Fischerspooner: Odyssey: Dull, dull, dull. Then again I only ever really liked two songs from the first album...

Royksopp: The Understanding: Boring. Nothing as interesting or pretty as on the previous album.

--------
Stuff I've bought but not gotten round to listening to properly yet:
Kate Bush - Aerial
Beck - Guero
Queens of the Stone Age last album

Looking forward to: Jeffrey and Jack Lewis' new album. Already out but am waiting for it to be posted.

ComradeBadger

02-01-2006, 01:43 AM

Down In Albion never came close to the brilliance of Up The Bracket :(
I'm sure Pete could do much better if he wasn't such a mess, although Kilamangiro, F*ck Forever and some other tracks are great.

Oh god no, nothing close to Up The Bracket, I just rather like it :p , it's nice to see Albion as a full track (although I miss the 'give over' and harmonica intro :E )

Also an interesting debut from the Subways. Produced some massive fun hits and I'll be looking forward to seeing what's ahead of them.

Oh Yeah in the indie club is bloody genius! :D A dancable-fave of mine.

I was undecided over Get Behind Me Satan... it seemed like the rock tunes of Elephant and Red Blood Cells were growing a bit distant and they needed to come more mainstream and that's where they went wrong. Apart from the sublime Blue Orchid, My Doorbell and The Nurse, the album ultimately sucked...

Yes. It's a shame, since I really liked the Detroit-garage-rock era of music (The Strokes' emergance, The Dirtbombs' infectious double-bassage, the magnificant Datsuns and the D4 ), and yes I'm aware they're not all from Detroit, but it's that sort of garage-rocknroll style!

I forgot to mention Franz Ferdinand's You Could Have It So Much Better, manages to be better than the first album, and very very good :D

Zephos

02-01-2006, 01:59 AM

jimbo118

02-01-2006, 01:25 PM

god the bravery's album sucked ass alright, loved bloc party's album, most of the tracks anyway, some were a bit :/, disappointed i missed their gig in the olympia :(

TheGMan.

02-01-2006, 02:31 PM

Worst
K-Fed's music. I could care less what the album name, but his music sucks and should burn in a lake for releasing music like that. He's bringing down the rap game by doing so.

Sprite

02-01-2006, 03:49 PM

god the bravery's album sucked ass alright, loved bloc party's album, most of the tracks anyway, some were a bit :/, disappointed i missed their gig in the olympia :(

Caught them at the Birmingham Academy, awesome stuff, and they have such a strong set for only one album.

EDIT:without listening, X&Y owns your mother****ing cat.

Haha, so true.

TheAntipop

02-01-2006, 04:28 PM

Best

Destruction - Inventor of Evil
Kreator - Enemy of God
Municipal Waste - Hazardous Mutation
The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute
Porcupine Tree - Deadwing
Bolt Thrower - Those Once Loyal
Strapping Young Lad - Alien
Dream Theater - Octavarium
Nevermore - This Godless Endeavor
Exodus - Shovel Headed Kill Machine
Meshuggah - Catch 33
Opeth - Ghost Reveries

I can't think of a worst. I can think of an album that doesn't deserve all the hype that it does get, and its that Trivium one. Boringblandgenericbleh.

stemot

02-01-2006, 04:43 PM

I appreciate that's your opinion, but that's my best album of 2005. Although there were a few songs that were pretty crap, it's a damn good album and Coldplay continue to improve. Fix You, White Shadows and Twisted Logic to name a few are fantastic.

Worst album? Oasis - Don't beleive the truth. I felt let down by this one. :(

Heh, I feel the exact opposite to you:-

Best:-

Oasis - Don`t Believe The Truth

The boys back to their glory days, with songs that, while not having the same agression of their early albums, resembles a mature, calmer band without so much something to say anymore, but still with the power to write some amazing songs.

Standout tracks:-

Lyla
The Importance Of Being Idle
Turn Up The Sun
Let There Be Love
Part Of The Queue
Keep The Dream Alive
Meaning Of Soul

Worst:-

Coldplay X&Y

This isn`t the worst album released this year by any stretch (that would fall to numerous r&b acts, in my opinion), but it`s by far the worst album this year from a band I used to think were amazing.
The whole thing, apart from Fix You, has bad lryics throughout, then when you put Chris Martin over the top with his high pitched whines and "woos" and "ahhhsss" all the way through, it amounts to nothing more than a band who didn`t want to risk changing to much, but in doing so, produced nothing more than a forgetable, and over-hyped album release.

But Fix You is a good song. :laugh:

KagePrototype

02-01-2006, 05:11 PM

MY two favourites were (Oceansize -- Everyone Into Position) and (The Mars Volta -- Frances the Mute). I'd probably rate Oceansize higher because it doesn't require having to sit through a few tracks at a time to appreciate it fully, but both are pretty much equals from my pov. :)

Sieg

02-01-2006, 05:51 PM

Desk clark of music store : " Will you just buy the damn CD so I can make a living instead of you writing down the names of albums?! "

Me: *Hands over paper with my msn* " Got a point, msn the names to me next time "

Dr. Freeman

02-01-2006, 06:12 PM

Best:

Nine Inch Nails - With Teeth (was 2005 i think?!) - simply awe inspiring

yeah, its really amazing how Trent can change his sound and still make amazing music..something most other bands can't do IMHO.
as always, i want more from Trent...he supposedly has some content for an album in 2006...plus hes been writing while on tour.. i can't wait :D

Audioslave: i think the new album was better than the past one but i do like them both.. wonder what they do for the next album

Evo

02-01-2006, 06:15 PM

Oh yeah Audioslave, an amazing album coupled with an amazing live show

evil^milk

02-01-2006, 06:44 PM

Kangy

02-01-2006, 10:24 PM

I'll have a 3 best and 3 worst, I think. And then 3 I couldn't decide on.

Best:
Ben Folds - Songs For Silverman

More stuff I just genuinely enjoyed from one of my favourite musicians. Also, doesn't sound anything like any of the other music I heard all year, which is genuinely good, considering how samey a lot of it was.

Arcade Fire - Funeral

It's been overrated, I know, but I don't buy a lot of that shite, I just went out on a suggestion from a mate and bought it, and it's pretty fantastic stuff. I've played it an awful lot since I got it.

Jack Johnson - In Between Dreams

Mmm, this one was very good for bus journeys and the like.

Undecided

The White Stripes - Get Behind Me Satan

I liked some of it, but a good portion left me sitting there, thinking "what the ****?" Could be worse, but I'd hoped for a lot better.

Antony & The Johnsons - I Am a Bird Now

He's got a stunning voice, but I only got this album last week, and I think it needs listening to with my earphones in rather than on my shitty speakers in order to properly rate.

Worst

Kaiser Chiefs - Employment

Tailor made "indie" or "alternative" or whatever the **** they were posing as. Get the **** out.

Coldplay - X&Y

Huge letdown, despite one or two good tracks. Rest of it was uninspired shit that felt like they were just reliving the past. Again.

Oasis - Don't Believe The Truth

Boring as hell.

Sprite

03-01-2006, 05:40 PM

room on fire was a disappointment? I loved it; but then again, I'm a Strokes fan. I've listened to the third album, and while I didn't like it at first, every song grew on me (except a few parts here and there) but let's wait for a proper thread to discuss what's good and bad about it.

Yeh, Is This It? is undoubtedly one of the best albums of the last 5-10 years... I felt that direction they took with Room On Fire was interesting but a bit mediocre. Sure it gave us 12:51 and Reptilia, but a lot of the album was just a lot of electronic fillers, which ultimately was a let down.

I got the third album today, and in a way the Strokes have really evolved. You are right, although to begin with it is hard to like, it grew on me after a while and is not bad at all.

Still... it's not Is This It? 2 :P

ComradeBadger

03-01-2006, 05:47 PM

Friend of mine got the new Strokes album today too, she really likes it, I think I'm gonna check it out :)

Stigmata

03-01-2006, 06:30 PM

Best

Gorillaz - Demon Days : This album is almost unbelievable. The beats are catchy, the sound is wonderful, and all the songs are great. Some say that Albarn phoned in his performance, to which I say..... well, I agree, but only on a couple songs, most noticeably Kids With Guns.

Standout tracks:
Feel Good Inc.
DARE
O Green World
Dirty Harry
Fire Coming Out of the Monkey's Head
El Manana
All Alone

And I don't care to list worst albums. I prefer not to think about them :p

ĐynastҰ

03-01-2006, 06:39 PM

Worst:-

Coldplay X&Y

This isn`t the worst album released this year by any stretch (that would fall to numerous r&b acts, in my opinion), but it`s by far the worst album this year from a band I used to think were amazing.
The whole thing, apart from Fix You, has bad lryics throughout, then when you put Chris Martin over the top with his high pitched whines and "woos" and "ahhhsss" all the way through, it amounts to nothing more than a band who didn`t want to risk changing to much, but in doing so, produced nothing more than a forgetable, and over-hyped album release.

But Fix You is a good song. :laugh:

i agree there. i saw an interview where they actually apologised about being too 'emotional' in the new album....i must say its a good slit-my-wrists CD..ahem...

Garfield_

03-01-2006, 06:55 PM

Best: Killswitch Engage - End Of Heartache 2005 ?
Worst: dunno, since im not bored of KSE yet :D

Anthraxxx

03-01-2006, 07:14 PM

Really Good Album: City of Evil by Avenged Sevenfold

JNightshade

03-01-2006, 07:29 PM

Best:
Sufjan Stevens - Illinois
Just... absolutely amazing album. Only Sufjan can write a song about a serial killer and show that he's human.

The Arcade Fire - Funeral
This is definitely a polarizing band, so I understand how someone can hate them. But I love 'em.

Wolf Parade - Apologies to the Queen Mary
Again, a polarizing band. But absolutely eeexcellent. "I'll Believe in Anything" is an amazing song.

Iron and Wine - Woman King
Beautiful, soft folk rock with really good lyrics and general awesomeness.

Broken Social Scene - Broken Social Scene
Absolutely wonderful. Sweeping soundscapes, a rush of audio all clashing yet working together perfectly.

Runners Up:

Deerhoof - The Runners Four
Wiiicked cool rock. Sounds a lot like Led Zep, amazingly.

Interpol - Antics
Not nearly as good as their first album, but still quite good in my opinion.

Worst:

No idea. Why would I spend time thinking about something I hate? I haven't heard any really bad albums this year, anyway.

ComradeBadger

03-01-2006, 07:39 PM

Oh god.. you just reminded me.

Broken Social Scene - Broken Social Scene.

MY GOD. It was rubbish. Literally unlistenable - in my opinion anyway :p

But hey, if you like it, it's cool :)

Dr. Freeman

03-01-2006, 07:42 PM

kaf11

03-01-2006, 08:00 PM

As of right now I only have a few of my favorites.

Best:

The Decemberists - Picaresque

Sufjan Stevens - Illinois

Oasis - Don't Beleive The Truth

Black Rebel Motorcycle Club - Howl

I'm also excited to go out and buy the new strokes album. I get paid on Thursday.

ComradeBadger

04-01-2006, 03:11 AM

I've just realised a track I mistakenly credited Interpol with was in fact Editors - Munich.

I apologise to Editors, and this just seals Antics' placing :p

IonizeMyAtoms

04-01-2006, 04:22 AM

The Vermicious Knid - Smalltown Devotion/Hometown Compulsion
****ing FANTASTIC

Icarusintel

04-01-2006, 04:57 AM

Absolute Best

Death Cab for Cutie - Plans

Quite simply, I could listen to this album completely on repeat until the day I die. There are no bad tracks, even if there are some that are my favorites. This is an incredible work, even if it can be very depressing. If you've never heard of Death Cab before definitely give this a try. If you have an open mind and love music you won't be disappointed.

Favorite Tracks -
"What Sarah Said" (My Most Favorite)
"Brothers on a Hotel Bed"
"Stable Song"
"Someday You Will be Loved"
"Summer Skin"
"Marching Bands of Manhattan"

Second Best

Buck 65 - This Right Here is Buck 65 (Best Of)

I actually just found this today, but it was released in 2005. The vocals remind me so much of Tom Waits, and the music is nice and mellow for most of it. Somehow it all just works together so well. Even though I just found this, it easily tops any other CD I heard in 2005, besides Plans.

Favorite tracks

"Cries a Girl" (Most Favorite)
"Wicked and Wierd"
"Roses and Bluejays"
"Talkin Fishing Blues"

IonizeMyAtoms

04-01-2006, 05:32 AM

Oh, I'd like to add Okkervil River's Black Sheep Boy. I listened to that album so many times in the past few weeks, the intensity in the singer's voice is wonderful
Oh, and Cuff The Duke's self titled was great

Trendkill

04-01-2006, 09:04 PM

Best
- Nevermore - This Godless Endeavor
*Amazing guitar work, Jeff Loomis is a machine. Warrells vocals add a lot to the songs.

- Opeth - Ghost Reveries
*Good riffs, good acoustic parts. Brilliant brutal parts and soft parts. And of course michaels incredable vocal work.

gick

05-01-2006, 11:30 AM

Propagandhi - Potemkin City Limits Awesome, amazing, politically fuelled progressive-thrash-hardcore-punk GENIUS. If you like your music intelligent, melodic, fast, heavy(ish) check it out. Also, lyrically one of the best albums ive heard in a looooong time.

Certainly not the worst album of the year, but I found Dropkick Murphys - The Warrior's Code to be the most disappointing. 4 or 5 excellent tracks on there, but lots of filler and even an example of poppy soft rock crap (Sunshine Highway).

IonizeMyAtoms

05-01-2006, 05:16 PM

I was really disappointed in the new Propagandhi. I miss their old stuff

theGreenBunny

05-01-2006, 05:27 PM

I'm just going to list some.

The Good of 2005
Wolf Parade - Apologies to the Queen Mary // just plain awesome

Clap Your Hands Say Yeah - Self Titled // strange name, strange vocals, strange music combine to form... fantastic album

The New Pornographers - Twin Cinema // as good as always, and more interesting than Electric Version

Spoon - Gimme Fiction // plain good

The Decemberists - Picaresque // everything they touch wins

Sufjan Stevens - Illinois // this is pretty orgasmic

The Bad of 2005
Everything from the UK (almost). I don't like this new brand of british indie rock at all. The Arctic Monkeys album I just listened to reminded me why (though I don't know if it's officially a 2005 album): Bland music, annoying punky vocals, inane lyrics (with the "I bet you look good on the dancefloor" track as the pinnacle). Gah. It's just not for me I guess.
I liked the Editors album at first, but it started to bore me after a week. Then I figured out they're really just an Interpol ripoff and listened to Turn On The Bright Lights instead.

IonizeMyAtoms

05-01-2006, 07:09 PM

Clap Your Hands Say Yeah! win my most over-rated award. Some good songs, but overall a big giant "meh" for me
I really liked the new Wolf Parade too, their 6 Song EP is my favourite of theirs
I will make love to the Decemberists. Some day.

Zeus

05-01-2006, 09:19 PM

A bit late for 2005...
But w/e.

Best : 10,000 Fists - Disturbed & Transgression - Fear Factory
Worst : In The End - Kittie

... meh I didn't buy many albums this year...

100% agreed on "Best"..and I havent heard your pick for worst album

so my pics for best are what lucid picked, 10k fists and transgression. For worst..hmm Im not sure yet

stemot

05-01-2006, 10:06 PM

Angry Lawyer

05-01-2006, 10:55 PM

Bon Jovi's "Have a Nice Day" - awesomeness in CD form.

-Angry Lawyer

Icarusintel

05-01-2006, 11:03 PM

Bon Jovi's "Have a Nice Day" - awesomeness in CD form.

-Angry Lawyer
I don;t listen to anything from Bon Jovi after "Slippery When Wet"

Angry Lawyer

06-01-2006, 08:07 PM

That's because you don't know how to ROCK OUT LIKE A LEGEND.

-Angry Lawyer

stemot

06-01-2006, 08:39 PM

That's because you don't know how to ROCK OUT LIKE A LEGEND.

-Angry Lawyer

Jovi lost my respect when he blatently ripped off an Oasis song (Stay Young) with "Captain Crush", and didn`t give them any credit whatsoever.

I know Oasis have been doing it for years, but they always put in the credits if they have used parts of anything else, and besides, I expected more from Bon Jovi considering he once said he was a fan.

His early stuff, like "Wanted, dead or alive" and "Always" will always be classics.

Polaris

06-01-2006, 09:30 PM

Mike Oldfield - Light and Shade - great album, fantastic music

Angry Lawyer

06-01-2006, 09:58 PM

Jovi lost my respect when he blatently ripped off an Oasis song (Stay Young) with "Captain Crush", and didn`t give them any credit whatsoever.

I know Oasis have been doing it for years, but they always put in the credits if they have used parts of anything else, and besides, I expected more from Bon Jovi considering he once said he was a fan.

His early stuff, like "Wanted, dead or alive" and "Always" will always be classics.

"Always" is pretty much a mid-career song D:

And it's "Captain Crash". Besides, they obviously didn't imitate the song enough to attract the attention of Oasis' lawyers, and therefore, they're not in the wrong.

And listening to Jovi makes women want to sleep with you. Proven fact.

-Angry Lawyer

IonizeMyAtoms

06-01-2006, 10:03 PM

I wouldn't want to sleep with a woman who listens to Bon Jovi

Angry Lawyer

06-01-2006, 10:17 PM

There are plenty of men, too.

-Angry Lawyer

IonizeMyAtoms

06-01-2006, 11:25 PM

:p
....

stemot

07-01-2006, 03:07 PM

"Always" is pretty much a mid-career song D:

And it's "Captain Crash". Besides, they obviously didn't imitate the song enough to attract the attention of Oasis' lawyers, and therefore, they're not in the wrong.

And listening to Jovi makes women want to sleep with you. Proven fact.

-Angry Lawyer

No, Oasis, as Noel has said numerous times about other bands nicking their stuff (the flash in the pan group, Hearsay, for one), that it would be hypocritical of Oasis to sue bands for ripping off their songs, seeing as Oasis have done it in the past (but always given credit and payed royalties).
Listen to Stay Young, they are near identical.

That doesn`t make it right on Jovi`s part, a simple credit in the sleeve would have been enough, so yes, maybe not legally wrong, no, only for the fact of Noel`s decision not to push it, but morally, he is.

Kangy

07-01-2006, 03:25 PM

No, Oasis, as Noel has said numerous times about other bands nicking their stuff (the flash in the pan group, Hearsay, for one), that it would be hypocritical of Oasis to sue bands for ripping off their songs, seeing as Oasis have done it in the past (but always given credit and payed royalties).
Listen to Stay Young, they are near identical.

That doesn`t make it right on Jovi`s part, a simple credit in the sleeve would have been enough, so yes, maybe not legally wrong, no, only for the fact of Noel`s decision not to push it, but morally, he is.

Yeah, Noel Gallagher shows how thankful he is all the time!

When George Harrison accused Oasis of being little more than a passing fad Noel commented "George was always the quiet Beatle, maybe he should keep that up" (this however, was not as threatening as his brother's promise to play golf off of Harrison's head should they ever meet).

stemot

07-01-2006, 03:42 PM

Yeah, Noel Gallagher shows how thankful he is all the time!

And that has to do with stealing copyrighted material how?

The only song Beatles song Oasis ever have covered is "I Am The Walrus", which is a Lennon/McCartney song, nothing to do with Harrison, other than that Oasis have used a few of Lennons lyrics in a couple of songs, and used a sample of "Imagine" at the start of "Don`t Look Back In Anger" but that is it, the only thing to do with Harrison is he was in the same band, he never wrote any of the lyrics used, and they never try to hide their influences or pass them off as their own.

But I agree he should have more respect for Harrison, he was part of the best band the countrys ever produced.

Anyway, lets get this back on topic,

My other favourite album of 2005 is:-

Doves:- Some Cities

Standout tracks:-

Black And White Town
Snowden
Walk In Fire
Some Cities
Sky Starts Falling

Kangy

07-01-2006, 03:47 PM

It's not about stealing, but Oasis take a lot of their work from The Beatles, and to go back and say that is kind of disrespectful and rude, really. That's all I'll say on the matter, though :)

Sprite

07-01-2006, 06:03 PM

Okay, after quite a few votes the current leaders with 3+ votes each are Bloc Party's Silent Alarm and Sufjan Steven's Illinois.

Although I myself am not a great fan of the singer/songwriter genre, Sufjan makes amazing music, and John Wayne Gacy, Jr. is one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard.

Of course, the worst album with -4 votes is currently The Bravery, but keep those votes coming!!

gick

08-01-2006, 03:04 PM

I was really disappointed in the new Propagandhi. I miss their old stuff

:O

When you say 'old', are you thinking Less Talk More Rock era or Today's Empires, Tommorrow's Ashes?

jmjneary

08-01-2006, 07:54 PM

Best
hyptonize/mezermise technically 2 cds but they are ment to be together

worst didnt like x & Y

Bohonkie

08-01-2006, 09:20 PM

My best album of the year would be Architecture in Helsinki. This Australian band includes so many awesome, unique elements in each of their songs that it's rediculous. Plus, they're just so much fun, I find it impossible to not love their songs. Definately check it out if you're a fan of similiar bands like Need New Body or the Avanlanches. Actually, **** that. Even if you've never heard of any of those bands, check out Architecture in Helsinki. You'll love them.

Worst album of the year...way too easy: Weezer-Make Believe. This album is an absolute emberassment to Pinkerton.

IonizeMyAtoms

08-01-2006, 09:48 PM

Architecture In Helsinki is so ****ing good. Completely agree

IonizeMyAtoms

08-01-2006, 09:49 PM

:O

When you say 'old', are you thinking Less Talk More Rock era or Today's Empires, Tommorrow's Ashes?
Less Talk More Rock and How To Clean Everything
Today's Ashes was okay, but I only liked about a quarter of it

DeusExMachina

08-01-2006, 10:24 PM

In Case We Die is an amazing album.

Bohonkie

08-01-2006, 10:31 PM

In Case We Die is an amazing album.

Yeah, thanks for mentioning that. I gave my album of the year without even mentioning the actual name of the album. Oops.

resiurC

11-01-2006, 07:11 AM

Best: Demon Days
Worst: I really can't think of right now.

brink's

11-01-2006, 01:18 PM

I'm suprised no one has picked wolf parade's apologies the queen marry or MIA's Arulry, both are top notch albums.

But my pick goes to illonois, so so so so good:D

JellyWorld

11-01-2006, 04:42 PM

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
Medulla - Bjork
Twin Cinema - The New Pornographers

Worst:
X&Y - Coldplay :|

Fliko

17-01-2006, 12:39 AM

Worst:
X&Y - Coldplay
Best:
None, I'm waiting for Lostprophets to release "Start Something", don't have a lot of bands I really watch for. Not a big music fan.

Tantalus

26-01-2006, 08:57 PM

I hope I'm not too late to post on this thread, but here are my favorite.

Octavarium, by Dream Theater. It may not be as good as their older stuff, but it's still awesome.

Plans, by Death Cab for Cutie. I've just recently started listening to indie, and I instantly fell in love with this album.

I noticed X&Y isn't very popular. I haven't heard any of it yet except Speed of Sound, which in my opinion is alright.

the_ghost_of_you

11-02-2006, 12:29 PM

I have gotta say Wolfmother takes the cake. This Aussie band is a releaving break from all the other usual jargon... LOVE THE HAIR GUYS ;)

Sparta

13-02-2006, 01:09 PM

Best Albums of 2005

Sufjan Stevens - Illinoise

No competition really. Its completely and utterly unique and awe-inspiring. A little weird at first, yeah, but after you get over that initial bump its one of the best albums out. Easily. And as previously mentioned anyone that can make a song about a notorious serial killer sound incredibly beautiful, is insanely talented.

Its a real shame he didn't even get nominated for a Grammy. Stupid awards are only handed out to popular artists and not those that deserve it.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Kickass album, love "Like Eating Glass". Awesome awesome song. Great voice, good drumming and some really haunting tracks.

Most Overrated Albums of the Year

Coldplay - X & Y

Just more of the same stuff really. Liked Rush of Blood to the Head, but "Speed of Sound" is "Clocks" with different lyrics. And everything else on the album just feels recycled. They're not progressing anymore. It's boring and makes me sleepy.

Gorillaz - Demon Dayz

This was just pretentious and boring. Besides two or three songs, its just a waste of space.

Homless Snark

13-02-2006, 09:52 PM

Best of 2005
================
1) Dream Theater - Octavarium
Info: Yes call me a homer/fanboy, but I adore dream theater, so the mere fact that it was released makes my top 5. Not to mention, outside of maybe 1 track, it's also a really good album.

2) John Petrucci - Suspended Animation
Info: The guitarist for DT proves his virtuosity here with his solo album that I thuroughly enjoyed. Not to mention him teaming up with G3.

3) Dragonforce - Inhuman Rampage
Info: Got this a little earlier then most, and I must say I really enjoyed it. Never heard Dragonforce until then. And while some may not enjoy the reptativeness or the constant fast-ass speed. I went out and bought there other 2 as soon as my ears were laid on this beauty.

4) The Mars Volta - Fances The Mute
Info: Definately an eye opener that got me into Mars Volta. I had heard about them before in the prog rock scene, but never payed much mind until recently and was glad I did.

5) Steve Vai - Real Illusions: Reflections
Info: Some people don't think it's Steve Vai's best. And it's not. But it's definately a great cd. I find myself listening to it more and more after an initial luke-warm reaction. With some interesting experimental tracks Steve Vai continues to evolve guitar playing.

6) Shadow Gallery - Room V
Info: I nice step for Shadow Gallery as they start to sound less power and more progressive in terms of metal. A solid album that should be picked up by any fans of the genres.

7) Black Label Society - Mafia
Info: More BLS? Not much needs to be said other then that. They are starting to run short on the creative side though.

8) Disturbed - Ten Thousand Fists
Info: Before when I didn't know much about music I used to listen to the top40 crap, and I liked Disturbed for there electronica/metal sound. They were one of the few bands that I still liked once my musical taste had evolved. When I found out they had a new album I was intrigued, and then heard they actually had solos, so I thought, why not? Picked it up, and I really like the CD. There are a couple filler songs. But overall it's more Disturbed with solos.

I I can't speak for worst, because I never buy albums of stuff I don't generally like so there's nothing that I own that would be put there
Nickelback - All The Right Reasons

craig

15-02-2006, 12:18 PM

Best of 2005 (in no particular order):

1. Elbow - Leaders of the Free World.
2. Editors - The Back Room.
3. Kaiser Chiefs - Employment.

Direwolf

15-02-2006, 08:43 PM

Twin Cinema - The New Pornographers
Hey! I'm not the only loser who listens to them!

ComradeBadger

16-02-2006, 06:45 PM

Hey! I'm not the only loser who listens to them!
I like them too :D

They're quite good, but not my best album of the year.

sullview

15-06-2006, 08:25 PM

Best:
Ben Folds - Songs For Silverman

More stuff I just genuinely enjoyed from one of my favourite musicians. Also, doesn't sound anything like any of the other music I heard all year, which is genuinely good, considering how samey a lot of it was.

Huzzah! A fellow Ben Folds fan. Definitely one of my favorite albums, not just for this year, but EVER. Jesusland FTW.